What is your favorite restaurant?
I’ve stopped having a favourite restaurant. Of the five that I would give as my favourite, four have closed and one has taken a dip in quality that has put us off going there.
Cafe Retro, Bath
Closed 2020-ish

When we first moved to Bath, we lived round the corner, from this place. It became our occasional Sunday treat, no-frills fried breakfast maybe once a month, evening meals maybe twice during the six years we lived in Bath. the decor is what might be called ‘eclectic’, with mis-matched chairs and no two tables looking alike. But the food is what matters.
I had breakfast there on the morning of our wedding, in the company of my best man, who also loved the place because their veggie food was brilliant.
Martini’s, Bath
Closed 2022

We loved the smell as we walked past on the way home from Sainsbury’s. Mainly garlic, some meaty and bready smell as well. We only went twice, because it was a bit expensive. Best dish was the chili chicken livers as a starter. I’ve tried to reproduce this since, but can’t quite get it right.
On our second visit, Chris Evans (the DJ) was having dinner with a huge group of friends.
Cafe Notturno, Melbourne
Closed 2023

“Nottie’s” as we knew it, was on Lygon St, Carlton in the heart of what was the Italian quarter. We visited often, they did great pizzas and the best cheesecake. When Mrs S was pregnant I would go there to get cheesecake for her. We also went there the evening Mrs S’s parents flew in to see their first grandchild. They have no memory of that meal.
They closed after 45 years some time before we revisited Melbourne in 2025. The site is now one of many Indian restaurants on the street – the diversity of cuisines has expanded somewhat in the 20 years we were away.
Tristan’s, Horsham
Closed 2022
The only Michelin starred restaurant I’ve been to more than once (been to one other ever). All four visits were wonderful experiences. The thing with very high quality food is that you don’t get a lot, but you’re full afterwards. Last time we went, we had the four course seasonal menu (below). Considering the quality of the food, £50 is a bargain especially with the occasional amuse bouche thrown in.

I had the crab, then quail, lamb and cheese afterwards. Previously we’d had rabbit and I even found a mushroom I like. Girolle1, which, of course, are chuffing expensive (about £1 each). I got a free tot of whisky (Monkey Shoulder, a blend of unpeated malts2) when we went on my birthday (my 50th, I think). They also serve wine of such quality even I could smell the blackberry in it (Boom Boom, California Red by Charles Smith). Normally, all I can smell in red wine is ‘wine’.
There’s a more complete review on this blog post by Major Foodie.
A pub (near Guildford)
We used to live going to this pub for Sunday lunch. It’s close to where my father-in-law is buried, it was my pick for my birthday meal at work after the company moved to Guildford. Unfortunately, it changed hands a few years ago and since then there’s something a bit off about the food, the service and the ambiance. We’re scouting for a new place in the area, there’s plenty of pubs around that do good food, but finding one we feel comfortable in may take time.
- Also known as chanterelle mushrooms. ↩︎
- Launched in 2005, Monkey Shoulder is intended as a cocktail whisky, but I’m very happy to drink it as is. They now do a ‘Smokey Monkey’ as well as the unpeated version. ↩︎




























